Murderer Michelle Sudků hides prison secret, journalist disbelieves

Michelle Sudků, convicted of murder in a Prague shopping centre, made a serious claim about her childhood to a documentary maker. Journalist Eretová refused to publish it – she does not believe it.

Murderer Michelle Sudků hides prison secret, journalist disbelieves

Sudků behind bars: secret the journalist refused to publish

Blesk.cz brings a new true crime podcast Dark Traces, whose first episode focuses on the case of Michelle Sudků – a woman who in July 2016 took a kitchen knife from a shelf in a Prague shopping centre on Smíchov and stabbed a randomly selected elderly woman in broad daylight. Other customers in the shop were still shopping. After the act, Sudků calmly sat down and waited for the police to arrive.

For murder and attempted murder – just two weeks before the fatal attack, she had tried to strangle another woman in a café on Prague's Újezd – Sudků was sentenced to an exceptional 30-year prison term. She is serving the sentence in a women's prison with security. Her family has distanced itself from her; she communicates with the outside world through letters, one of which she wrote to the podcast presenter Bára Holá.

Face-to-face meeting: "I was never so nervous"

Journalist and documentary maker Martina Eretová met Sudků directly in the prison while filming the documentary series Without Remorse. She accepted an invitation to the first episode of the Dark Traces podcast and recalls this meeting as exceptionally disturbing.

"I was never as nervous as I was with her," Eretová said in the podcast. Although she has filmed with more than twenty murderers in her career, Sudků stood out according to her. "With her I felt she was unpredictable. I cannot logically argue this, though," she added.

During the conversation behind bars, Sudků told her a serious claim concerning her adoptive father and an event from her childhood. Eretová decided not to publish this information.

"She told me something that according to her happened in childhood, it has a connection to her father and was quite serious. But I didn't put it in the documentary, and I won't say here what it is about, because I simply don't believe her at all," explained the documentary maker. The content of the claim remains a secret; Eretová decided not to spread unsubstantiated information further.

Two weeks before the murder: attack in a café and psychiatric stay

Sudků's story did not begin in the shopping centre. Two weeks before the murder, she attacked a woman in a café on Újezd and tried to strangle her. People present intervened and called the police. This was followed by a short stay in a psychiatric hospital, after which Sudků was released.

According to Eretová, Sudků had her own explanation: "She felt she should be hospitalised and that they were being unfair to her. She decided to prove to the doctors that she really belonged there."

The victim's family obtained compensation of 8.5 million crowns for police failings in connection with this case.

"One cannot blame people for everything"

Eretová also penetrated the convicted woman's personal story during filming. Sudků spoke about a complicated childhood, adoptive parents and a feeling that she was never truly loved in the family. The journalist, however, receives her accounts with reservation.

"I see it so that of course it is her version of the story," she says openly.

The question of whether a person is born a murderer or becomes one due to circumstances, Eretová considers particularly complex in Sudků's case. "Whereas with most of the murdered women I tend towards the view that they gradually ended up on the path of crime and their life fates led them to murder, with Michelle I really have the feeling that she got the wrong genetic equipment from the beginning," she says.

A trace that remained in the documentary maker

The case left a lasting mark on Eretová herself. "Since then I have felt that a person cannot really be completely safe anywhere. Perhaps at home on the sofa or in bed," she admitted.

The Dark Traces podcast is released every other Thursday on Blesk.cz and in podcast applications.

Source: Blesk.cz

Read this article in the original language