Childcare worker Rita acquitted after 20 years: convicted in 2019, now cleared by appeals court

Rita, former childcare worker for one-year-old Martine, has been acquitted by Eidsivating lagmannsrett of causing the girl's death in 2006. The 2019 conviction for four years' imprisonment has thus been overturned.

Childcare worker Rita acquitted after 20 years: convicted in 2019, now cleared by appeals court

Childcare worker acquitted after 20 years: – I know I did nothing to harm Martine

Rita, who in 2019 was sentenced to four years' imprisonment for injuring one-year-old Martine so fatally that the girl died, has this week been acquitted by Eidsivating lagmannsrett. This is reported by nrk.no.

– If it should be described in one word, then I am exhausted. And then there is chaos in my head. Joy, sorrow and frustration over what I have been through, Rita tells NRK.

Martine died in 2006 from extensive brain haemorrhaging and brain damage after falling into a coma at Rita's home. Rita has consistently denied any knowledge of having harmed the child.

Four years in prison – nine months in high security

Despite her denial, Rita was in 2019 convicted to four years' imprisonment. She spent the first nine months in a high-security prison in the middle of the pandemic in 2020.

For Rita, the hardest part of serving her sentence was not the prison walls themselves, but being separated from her own three children.

– I never saw my son in his graduation attire. And I was not allowed to attend my middle daughter's leaving ceremony in tenth grade, she says.

– It was very sad, and I feel that I have missed out on a great deal.

Rita describes the separation from her children as worse than the prison stay itself.

The ruling came via email

When the court's decision came down on Monday morning, Rita was having a late breakfast with a friend. Her mobile phone lay on the table.

Then an email from the court came through on her phone.

– I shouldn't open that, Rita said to her youngest daughter and her friend.

Rita had arranged with her defence lawyer, Thomas Randby, that she would wait for his phone call before reading the judgment.

– You are certainly hard-boiled, her friend said to Rita.

Six of seven judges for acquittal

The judgment was delivered with dissent. Six of seven judges believed that Rita should be acquitted of the charge of harming Martine. One of the lay judges, however, wished to continue to convict her to imprisonment.

The defence lawyers, including Thomas Randby, argued during the trial that it cannot be proved beyond reasonable doubt that Rita killed Martine. Randby has previously suggested to NRK that Rita may have been the victim of a miscarriage of justice – a characterisation that Rita herself has not yet fully been able to come to terms with.

Prosecutor Christer Gangsø and Ellisiv Emblem Bentdal, who represented the prosecution, tell NRK that they note that the court has assessed the evidence differently from them. They will now examine the judgment thoroughly and send their recommendation to Riksadvokaten, who will decide whether the case should be appealed to the Supreme Court.

The prosecution has two weeks

The judgment is not yet final. The prosecution has two weeks to appeal the case to the Supreme Court. If this happens, Rita must go through another round of court proceedings.

Marius Mørner Staurset, legal representative for Martine's parents, tells NRK that the parents find it difficult not to get a proper answer to what happened to their daughter.

– But I am surprised that there is such great disagreement among competent doctors about the causes and mechanisms of injury, and that the view is apparently quite different today than just a few years ago, in 2019, says Staurset.

Martine's parents have themselves at all times denied having caused their daughter harm.

– Now we are just glad about what is good

Rita says that she has not yet had time to think about what happens going forward, now that she has been acquitted.

– Now we are just glad about what is good now. I cannot grieve over something that has not yet happened, she says.

Rita tells that knitting has helped her through her daily life, and that both Martine's parents and her own family have gone through the same trauma with the same feelings.

For Rita, it was important to be open in the local community, so that people knew the truth – a stance she has maintained for all 20 years.

Source: Google News DK — Crime (da)

Read this article in the original language