Father of Isidora could be released from preventive detention following Santiago court ruling

The Fourth Guarantee Court in Santiago revoked the preventive detention of Jorge Constanzo, accused in the death of his 2-year-old daughter. The Public Prosecutor's Office appealed and the Court of Appeals will decide on the precautionary measures.

Father of Isidora could be released from preventive detention following Santiago court ruling

Court classifies Isidora's death as quasi-delict and revokes preventive detention of her father

The Fourth Guarantee Court in Santiago revoked on Thursday the preventive detention of Jorge Constanzo, accused in the death of his daughter Isidora, 2 years and 8 months old, who fell from the 11th floor of a building in the Las Condes district last May. According to biobiochile.cl, the court ordered night-time house arrest and national travel restriction in its place.

During the hearing to review precautionary measures, the court determined that the evidence in the case does not constitute the crime of homicide by omission, but rather a quasi-delict of homicide. With that classification, the judge resolved to replace the preventive detention that Constanzo had been serving for six months in the Preventive Detention Centre (CDP) in Casablanca, in the Valparaíso Region.

The decision is not final: the Metropolitan East Public Prosecutor's Office appealed orally in court, so it will be the Santiago Court of Appeals that determines what precautionary measures the accused must comply with whilst the investigation continues.

The Public Prosecutor's Office appeals and maintains it is homicide

Fiscal Ezio Braghetto, of the East Gender Public Prosecutor's Office, acknowledged that the scenario was foreseeable, but insisted on his position. "The legal classification is quite complex and debatable. From the first ruling it was and it has been constantly. Therefore, the ruling is not surprising necessarily, but evidently we do not agree with it", he stated.

Braghetto added that the Public Prosecutor's Office has arguments to sustain before the Court the maintenance of preventive detention. "We believe that we have important grounds to be able to maintain in the appeal the preventive detention of the accused with the grounds and the proceedings that we have been carrying out so far", the prosecutor said.

The fiscal also clarified that the court's classification is provisional. "For the Public Prosecutor's Office it continues to be a homicide case. So much so that we have appealed to maintain that legal classification. Therefore, the final ruling will be issued by the Court of Appeals", he added.

The defence argues there was negligence, not intent

Paula Vial, new defence counsel for Constanzo, explained that in recent weeks the team obtained evidence that had not been presented in previous hearings. "They made it possible to correct some errors in the narrative that had been established up until now", she stated.

Vial argued that the evidence gathered proves that there was permanent care on the part of the father towards the girl, smooth coordination with the mother, and that the reaction on the day of the events was late, but within timeframes different from those previously suggested. "What we were able to prove is that there had been permanent care, concern, a very good relationship of coordination with her mother, and specifically on that day also a late reaction, unfortunately, but within different timeframes from those that had been proposed", the lawyer elaborated.

Asked about the evidence pointing to Constanzo driving whilst intoxicated with the girl in the vehicle during that day, Vial responded without hesitation that this circumstance does not contradict the defence's position.

"This is not a competition, an evaluation of good fathering. We were discussing whether there was an intentional crime, even if by omission, or one involving negligence. And we maintain that what occurred, within the tragedy that this represents, was negligence, and fortunately, the judge agreed with that so far, at least", concluded Vial.

The final resolution, in the hands of the Court of Appeals

With the Public Prosecutor's Office's oral appeal lodged in the same hearing, the precautionary situation of Jorge Constanzo remains suspended until the Santiago Court of Appeals issues its ruling. The accused could leave the CDP in Casablanca if the appellate court confirms the decision of the Fourth Guarantee Court, or else continue in preventive detention if it accepts the arguments of the Public Prosecutor's Office.

The investigation continues. The case revolves around Isidora's fall from the 11th floor of a building in Las Condes last May, and the central legal dispute is whether the father acted with intent—even if by omission—or whether it was a negligent act.

Source: Google News CL — Crime

Read this article in the original language