Three convicted of robbery with homicide of cyclist in Recoleta: sentences of up to 17 years

Santiago's Second Criminal Trial Court convicted three co-perpetrators of the robbery with homicide of Luis Enrique Pardo Benavides, which occurred in October 2024 in Recoleta.

Three convicted of robbery with homicide of cyclist in Recoleta: sentences of up to 17 years

Unanimous ruling convicts three men for death of cyclist in Recoleta

Santiago's Second Criminal Trial Court unanimously convicted Michel Jonathan Hernández Carrillo, Roberto Andrés Cifuentes Villagra and Jonnathan Anthony Barrera Cifuentes of the crime of robbery with homicide, according to g5noticias.cl. The three were found to be co-perpetrators of the crime committed on 20 October 2024 in the municipality of Recoleta.

The custodial sentences were set at 17 years for Hernández Carrillo, 16 years for Cifuentes Villagra and 15 years and one day for Barrera Cifuentes. The court, composed of judges María Carolina Hernández Muñoz—who presided—, Alejandra Rodríguez Oro and Nelson González Valenzuela as rapporteur, resolved the case under case number 251-2026.

Established facts

The court established, beyond reasonable doubt, that at approximately 01:11 hours on 20 October 2024, on Avenida Recoleta at number 3126, the three accused were travelling in a grey Kia Avella vehicle, licence plate TD-1220. Roberto Cifuentes remained at the wheel whilst Hernández Carrillo and Barrera Cifuentes got out of the car.

Both approached Luis Enrique Pardo Benavides, who was walking whilst carrying his black mountain bicycle. During the struggle for the item, Michel Hernández stabbed him in the chest with a sharp weapon, whilst Jonnathan Barrera provided cover. After taking the bicycle, the three fled in the same vehicle. The victim died shortly afterwards as a result of a penetrating thoracic cardiac wound.

Proportionality criteria in determining sentences

The court applied article 433 no. 1 of the Penal Code, which punishes robbery with homicide with the maximum degree of major imprisonment to qualified life imprisonment. In its ruling, the judges noted that there was a mitigating circumstance of criminal responsibility in favour of the three defendants and that there were no aggravating factors against them, which allowed the sanctions to be imposed at the lowest level of the sentence range.

However, within that margin, the court weighed the extent of the damage caused and the specific conduct of each convicted person. The highest sentence was imposed on Hernández Carrillo for being the principal perpetrator of the death. Cifuentes Villagra received an intermediate sentence, taking into account his conduct after the crime—which included the disposal of the stolen item and his attempts to conceal it in the vehicle during the following morning. For Barrera Cifuentes, the base sentence of the range was considered proportional, given that his participation was limited to providing cover during the act and he had little further involvement in the disposal of the bicycle afterwards.

In the sentence, the court emphasised that it sought to maintain for each offender "harmony with the principle of proportionality of sentences", so that the punitive response would accord with the seriousness of the attack on the legal right and with the particular forms of commission.

No option for substitute sentences

The ruling expressly ruled out the possibility of applying substitute sentences, given the sentence range that was to be imposed. As a result, the three convicted offenders must serve their respective sentences in full.

Additionally, the court imposed on all three the legal accessory penalties of absolute perpetual disqualification from public office and political rights, as well as absolute disqualification from the practice of professions during the time their sentences last.

Source: Google News CL — Santiago

Read this article in the original language