Trial of ex-RBB chief Schlesinger: embezzlement and systemic failure

In Berlin, former RBB director Patricia Schlesinger faces charges in regional court on 26 counts of embezzlement. The trial shines a light on mismanagement in public-service broadcasting.

Trial of ex-RBB chief Schlesinger: embezzlement and systemic failure

Schlesinger in court – and with her, the system of public-service broadcasting

Before the Regional Court in Berlin, Patricia Schlesinger, director of Rundfunk Berlin-Brandenburg (RBB) from 2016 to 2022, must answer 26 counts of embezzlement. The prosecutor alleges total damages of around 2 million euros. As NZZ reports, however, behind this individual case lies a profound structural problem: self-enrichment and waste throughout public-service broadcasting.

The charges against Schlesinger in detail

According to the indictment, Schlesinger is alleged to have approved unauthorised bonus payments to management totalling nearly one million euros while bypassing the administrative board. Added to this are disproportionate severance agreements and early retirements with long-serving staff that allegedly caused damage of around 700,000 euros.

Further charges concern monthly allowances of 1,700 euros for senior executives during the RBB's chairmanship of the ARD, as well as the billing of approximately 7,000 euros in expenses for ten dinners in her private apartment and a trip to London with her husband. Her final annual salary was 300,000 euros. Public attention was also drawn to the massage seat in her official vehicle, an Audi A8, as well as costly renovation work in her office featuring parquet flooring and designer furniture.

The defence counters: Schlesinger's lawyers argue that bonuses and allowances were known to the responsible oversight bodies and corresponded to compensation systems common in many public institutions.

A practice that Schlesinger inherited

This account gains plausibility through concrete cases. For example, in late 2016, then RBB programme director Claudia Nothelle left the broadcaster prematurely. The 52-year-old has since been receiving a pension of 8,437 euros per month – for life, even though at the time of her departure she was clearly capable of working and had around fifteen years remaining until regular retirement. By the time she reaches pension age, her entitlements alone total more than one million euros. Shortly after her dismissal, Nothelle took up a professorship in television journalism.

Adding to the problem is the fact that the RBB failed to include a contractual clause that would have offset any subsequent income against her pension. The self-enrichment mentality, according to NZZ, was already rampant at the RBB before Schlesinger took office.

Cost explosions in the system

Beyond the criminal trial, the construction policies of public-service broadcasters are also coming under scrutiny. Westdeutscher Rundfunk (WDR) initially budgeted the renovation of its Film House, built in 1974, at 65 to 80 million euros; most recently, costs of 240 million euros have been projected. The RBB planned a Digital Media House for 63 million euros but stopped the project after planning costs exploded to 311 million euros – an increase of around 500 per cent. Similar developments occurred in the renovation of Deutschlandfunk's high-rise building in Cologne and a new construction by Bayerischer Rundfunk (BR) in Munich.

Self-promotion and system criticism

Parallel to the ongoing trial, the self-presentation of leading ARD directors is drawing criticism. Kai Gniffke, director of Südwestrundfunk (SWR) and the highest-paid station manager in the ARD with an annual salary of 400,000 euros, wrote on LinkedIn that public-service broadcasters stand for "ethical and professional standards, journalistic independence and quality". ZDF director Norbert Himmler stated: "Who, if not us, must guarantee freedom of opinion and plurality?"

Gniffke justified his salary in an interview with the ARD magazine "Panorama" by saying he bears "responsibility every day for 15 million people" – a figure referring to all persons living in the SWR broadcast area, who nonetheless must pay a monthly mandatory fee to the broadcaster.

WDR presenter Jörg Schönenborn, formerly the station's programme director, also invoked constitutional doctrine: public-service broadcasting ensures "the functioning of our democracy".

Individual wrongdoer or symptom?

In public perception, Schlesinger appears as a scapegoat for a practice that, according to her defence team's assessment, she merely continued. Whether the prosecution can refute this view will be decided by the Regional Court in Berlin.

The trial is likely to raise questions beyond the individual case about the oversight mechanisms within the public-service broadcasting system designed to prevent compensation and contract structures from growing out of control. Answers to these questions cannot be provided by the prosecution alone.

Source: NZZ

Read this article in the original language