Italian jeweller sentenced to 14 years and 9 months for killing two thieves in Grinzane Cavour

The Court of Cassation has definitively confirmed the conviction of jeweller Mario Roggero, who pursued and shot the thieves after a robbery. Compensation of €480,000 has not yet been paid.

Italian jeweller sentenced to 14 years and 9 months for killing two thieves in Grinzane Cavour

Definitively convicted: the jeweller from Cuneo who pursued his thieves on the street

The Court of Cassation has definitively sentenced jeweller Mario Roggero from Grinzane Cavour, province of Cuneo, to 14 years and 9 months' imprisonment for killing two thieves and injuring a third, following the attack on his shop on 28 April 2021. According to G4Media, citing Corriere della Sera, the judges found that Roggero "intended to take justice into his own hands".

The ruling of 15 July from the first criminal section of the Court of Cassation confirms the reasoning of the lower courts: Roggero did not act through negligence or a mistaken assessment of danger, but "through a voluntary and conscious choice oriented his action along the path of deliberate aggression, not justified by any necessity of self-defence".

Shots fired after the robbery ended

The central element of the court's reasoning is the moment when the gunshots were fired. The judges emphasise that "Roggero pursued the thieves outside the jewellery shop, firing shots at a moment when the robbery had already ended, and the offenders were about to flee".

Furthermore, the court finds that "the fatal act was committed at a moment when the danger to the life and physical integrity of his relatives had already ceased to exist, as the accused himself had the opportunity to clearly perceive". The lethal intent was inferred "from the rapid succession of multiple gunshots, aimed at human height and from close range, in the direction of the victims".

Compensation of €480,000 unpaid

The definitive ruling opens the way for the resolution of the matter of civil compensation, which remains unresolved. The lawyer for the family of Giuseppe Mazzarino, one of the two thieves killed, Giuseppe Roberto Caruso, clarifies that the provisional amounts set by the court — totalling €480,000 — have not yet been paid by Roggero.

"A civil action is already underway to obtain compliance with the provisions," declared lawyer Careglio, representing the family of the other murdered thief, Andrea Spinelli. He clarifies that the parties reserve the right to pursue a civil suit to fully quantify the damages, now that the Court of Cassation's ruling has been officially filed.

Lawyer Careglio was unwilling to provide details regarding the possibility of seeking compensation from the jewellery business activity, an enterprise still managed by Mariangela Sandrone, Roggero's wife.

Both lawyers for the victims' families confirm that they would consider a "global settlement" of the compensation matter without resorting to a separate civil trial. To date, however, "no proposal has ever been made by the other party", according to their statements.

The lawyer for the Spinelli family characterised the court's ruling as "legally irreproachable".

Source: G4Media

Read this article in the original language