Court of Cassation: Roggero convicted, assault was not legitimate self-defence
The Court of Cassation has upheld the 14 years and 9 months conviction for Mario Roggero, the jeweller who in 2021 pursued and killed two robbers. The judges rule out self-defence.

Cassation confirms: defence not legitimate in Roggero case
According to Il Fatto Quotidiano – Cronaca, the Court of Cassation has made final the reasons for the conviction to 14 years and nine months against Mario Roggero, a jeweller from Grinzane Cavour (Cuneo). The judges write that Roggero acted "with voluntary and conscious choice" in a "deliberate assault not justified by the necessity of defence".
In April 2021, Roggero pursued and killed two robbers of his jewellery shop, wounding a third. The Court of Appeal of Turin had already ruled out the existence of self-defence, actual or putative. The Cassation has confirmed this assessment, noting that the homicidal conduct was carried out at a time when "the danger to life and personal safety had already ceased": Roggero had pursued the robbers outside the shop after the robbery was already concluded and the criminals were intent on fleeing.
In the sentence, the Supreme Court also rejected the defence's reconstruction. Roggero's lawyer had suggested that the robbers could have changed their mind and returned to the jewellery shop to threaten the safety of the people present. The judges defined this hypothesis as "lacking any factual basis", made implausible by the already accomplished taking of the stolen goods and the proximity to the car intended for escape.
The Cassation has identified in the elements of Roggero's conduct "unambiguously indicative of the intention to take the law into his own hands". The defendant himself, in interviews released after the events, had stated that the initiative was the only way to stop the robbers and hand them over to justice. For the judges, however, this was not a matter of self-defence but rather of a deliberate choice to protect himself, exceeding the limits of necessity and proportionality required by law.
Source: Il Fatto Quotidiano - Cronaca