Supreme Court of Justice reduces Manuel Pinho's sentence from 10 to 8 and a half years for corruption
The Supreme Court of Justice reduced the sentence of the former Economy Minister from 10 to 8 years and 6 months of effective imprisonment. The defence announced an appeal to the Constitutional Court, which suspends execution of the sentence.
Supreme Court of Justice mitigates Manuel Pinho's sentence in GES-related corruption case
The Supreme Court of Justice (STJ) reduced the sentence of Manuel Pinho, former Economy Minister under José Sócrates, from 10 years to 8 years and 6 months of effective imprisonment on Thursday. According to SIC Notícias, the decision comes one year and four months after the Lisbon Court of Appeal confirmed the initial conviction in April 2025.
Manuel Pinho had been sentenced in June 2024 by the Lisbon Central Criminal Court for two offences of passive corruption for unlawful acts, one offence of tax fraud and one offence of money laundering. At issue is the alleged receipt of approximately 4.9 million euros, including a monthly payment of roughly 15,000 euros paid by the Espírito Santo Group (GES) slush fund, through accounts in Switzerland opened in the name of offshore companies, whilst he was part of José Sócrates' first Government.
Supreme Court of Justice's justification
In a statement released to the media, the court justified the mitigation by reference to the time elapsed since the offences were committed. "Despite the considerable gravity of the offences committed, considering the overall picture of the facts and of the accused's character — the prolonged period elapsed since the commission of the offences, the absence of criminal records and new criminal conduct, the accused's current age, his family and social integration, his removal from public office in whose context the criminal activity occurred and the reduction in current requirements for special deterrence — the STJ decided that a more substantial mitigating assessment is justified than that recognised by the lower courts," the statement reads.
The STJ added that "general positive deterrence, although particularly demanding, can be satisfied by a sentence lower than that applied, which continues to represent a severe and unequivocal criminal sanction for the criminal conduct". The court further clarified that it had "jurisdiction only to rule on the single sentence applied" to Manuel Pinho, namely the 10 years, and not on each individual sentence for each of the offences.
Appeal to the Constitutional Court
Lawyer Ricardo Sá Fernandes, who has represented Manuel Pinho's defence since the beginning of the proceedings, immediately announced an appeal to the Constitutional Court. Under the law, this appeal has suspensory effect, meaning that the execution of the effective prison sentence determined by the STJ is suspended whilst the proceedings are ongoing.
Sá Fernandes argues that STJ case law prevents consideration of "questions relating to individual sentences of less than 8 years", which was the case for the sentences imposed on Manuel Pinho. The defence "considers" that such a position is "unconstitutional and violates the principle of a fair trial".
House arrest since 2021 and possible conditional release
Manuel Pinho, aged 71, has been under house arrest since December 2021. Taking into account the almost five years already served under this regime, the actual execution of the prison sentence could be substantially lower — or could even not occur.
With the eventual final judgment of the STJ's decision, the former minister could benefit from conditional release if the Court of Execution of Sentences (TEP) so determines. The time spent under house arrest already served — four years and ten months — exceeds half of the sentence of eight years and six months set by the judge members, which would correspond to four years and three months. However, Manuel Pinho must formally begin execution of the sentence in order for the TEP to be able to consider possible conditional release.
Other convicted persons in the same case
In the same trial in June 2024, former banker Ricardo Salgado was sentenced to six years and three months of imprisonment for corruption and money laundering — a sentence that became final and was subsequently consolidated into a single sentence of 13 years, due to a second conviction in the Operation Marquês investigation, suspended due to the Alzheimer's disease from which he suffers. Alexandra Pinho, the wife of the former minister, was sentenced to four years and eight months of suspended sentence for tax fraud and money laundering.
Manuel Pinho had also been sentenced to pay the State a sum of 4.9 million euros. Thursday's decision from the STJ related only to the single prison sentence.
Source: SIC Notícias