Kerry councillor Jackie Healy-Rae settles assault civil case for €80,000

Kerry county councillor Jackie Healy-Rae has settled a civil lawsuit arising from a 2017 assault in Kenmare for around €80,000. The case was struck out at Tralee Circuit Court.

€80,000 settlement reached in Healy-Rae assault civil case

Kerry county councillor Jackie Healy-Rae has settled a civil lawsuit connected to his 2017 assault of Kieran James in Kenmare, the Irish Independent reports. The settlement is understood to be in the region of €80,000 in compensation for Mr James.

Solicitor Pat Mann informed Judge Alec Gabbett at Tralee Circuit Court that the parties had reached an agreement. Proceedings were struck out, and no further details of the settlement were disclosed in court.

The case first came before the court on 22 April and returned later that month on a motion for judgment in default of defence. It was adjourned at that point to allow the defendants to file their defence before ultimately being settled.

Plaintiff Kieran James (38), of Maxim Road, Grange Park, London, had claimed €60,000 for personal and psychological injuries, loss, damage and expenses. He brought the personal injuries action against Jackie Healy-Rae, his brother Kevin Healy-Rae — both sons of Independent TD and former junior minister Michael Healy-Rae — and their friend Malachy Scannell.

All three were convicted in December 2019 of assault causing harm to Mr James following a highly publicised criminal case. The assault took place in Kenmare on 28 December 2017, after Mr James's partner told a chip-van server that Kevin Healy-Rae had jumped the queue, triggering a confrontation between the group.

Jackie Healy-Rae subsequently lost his Circuit Court appeal against the criminal conviction in October 2022. The presiding judge at the time found that he had lied to gardaí when questioned about the incident. His co-defendants did not appeal.

Jackie Healy-Rae received two concurrent suspended sentences of three and five months for assault causing harm. Kevin Healy-Rae received a seven-month suspended sentence for assault causing harm to Mr James, while Malachy Scannell received two six-month suspended sentences — one for the assault on Mr James and one relating to a separate individual.

The civil court summons, submitted in April and viewed by The Kerryman, stated that the defendants acted "with a common design and are sued jointly, severally and/or in the alternative". It alleged Mr James was "intentionally and with hostility and force, repeatedly assaulted and beaten by the defendants who pushed and struck the plaintiff and went to choke him around the neck".

According to the claim, emergency services brought Mr James to Kerry University Hospital for assessment, with particular attention to "damage to his face sustained by several heavy facial blows". He subsequently required surgery in 2018 to reshape a fractured nose and was left with a permanent nasal deformity as well as ongoing shoulder problems.

The claim also referenced personal ties Mr James has to the area — his mother is originally from Kilgarvan.

When The Kerryman attended the first court appearance on 22 April, the summons issued by J Cashell Solicitors incorporating Patrick Mann and Company was not listed among the public cases of the day. It was called in a near-empty courtroom at the very end of proceedings.

Source: Irish Independent