Social media platforms ignore own fraud rules, Dublin appeals body finds

Appeals Centre Europe found that 86% of reported scam content left up by platforms actually broke their own rules. The Dublin-based body handled 43,000 disputes in a year.

Social media platforms ignore own fraud rules, Dublin appeals body finds

Scam content stays up despite reports, EU appeals body warns

Social media platforms are routinely leaving up fraud and scam content after it has been reported — even when that content violates their own policies, according to a new transparency report from Appeals Centre Europe, as thejournal.ie reports.

The Dublin-based appeals body, which handles disputes from social media users across Ireland and the EU, examined more than 1,000 cases in which platforms declined to remove content flagged as potential fraud. It found the content breached platform rules in 86% of those cases.

Fraud and scams top the dispute charts

The report, covering October 2025 to September 2026, recorded 43,000 disputes in total — an average of one every 12 minutes. Across the EU, fraud and scams generated more eligible disputes than any other category during the April-to-September 2026 period.

From Ireland alone, the centre received around 770 disputes. Approximately 280 were deemed eligible and forwarded to the relevant platforms. The majority — 62% — of Irish disputes challenged account suspensions, with Facebook receiving the highest volume of eligible complaints.

Of the more than 16,800 decisions issued during the reporting period, the centre disagreed with the platform 74% of the time when it was able to review the content — a 15-percentage-point increase compared to the previous transparency report.

Overturn rates varied significantly by platform: YouTube had the highest rate at 93%, followed by TikTok at 77%, Instagram at 75%, and Facebook at 67%.

AI-generated scams cited as growing threat

The centre highlighted several examples of fraud content that platforms had left up despite reports. These included an AI-generated "romance scam" video on TikTok featuring a woman claiming to seek a committed relationship, with the apparent aim of extracting money from viewers.

A Facebook video showed an AI-generated deepfake of a Moldovan economic expert promising a 2,000% return on investment. A YouTube video about cryptocurrency directed users to copy ChatGPT code via a link in the caption — a method the centre said likely gives scammers access to victims' crypto accounts.

The centre said AI-generated content is making it increasingly difficult for users to distinguish genuine material from fraudulent imitations.

Platforms withholding content from review

Beyond scam cases, the centre raised concerns about platforms failing to share the content underlying account suspension decisions. In 10,000 decisions — predominantly related to suspensions — the centre did not receive the content from the platform and issued a procedural decision in favour of the user.

Progress has been made: the number of decisions issued after the centre actually received content rose from around 10 in May 2026 to nearly 100 by September. However, the centre said the vast majority of suspension cases still proceed without platforms providing the relevant material.

Google was identified as the most problematic in this regard. Despite the centre requesting more than 850 pieces of content between October 2025 and September 2026, Google provided just two.

A further 1,950 decisions found that cases fell outside the scope of Article 21 of the EU's Digital Services Act, resulting in procedural decisions in favour of the platform.

Decisions overturned across platforms

Among the cases where the centre disagreed with platform decisions were an Instagram account banned under Meta's counterfeiting rules — which appeared to belong to a legitimate Italian retailer selling genuine goods — and a YouTube video from the page of Golden Dawn, which should have been removed under the platform's rules on criminal organisations.

A TikTok video claiming the Valencia flash floods were caused by climate engineering was also flagged; the centre found it should have been restricted under the platform's misinformation policy.

Since its establishment, the centre has processed more than 65,000 disputes in total from across the EU. France submitted the highest number of eligible disputes, followed by Belgium and Spain. To cope with the increase in caseload, the centre said its Dublin-based case review team has doubled in the past three months.

Centre calls for stronger enforcement

Thomas Hughes, chief executive of Appeals Centre Europe, said scams cause serious harm to individuals. "From stealing people's savings to impacting their mental health, scams destroy lives," he said. "Social media should not be a safe haven for scammers."

Hughes added that users in the EU have the right to challenge platform decisions when platforms fail to enforce their own rules, and directed people to submit disputes at appealscentre.eu.

Source: Google News IE — Crime (en)