Vitals fraud case: defence seeks to strike expert witness evidence in Malta court
Defence lawyers in the Vitals hospital concession case have asked the court to expunge evidence from two court-appointed experts, citing qualification concerns and deliberate evasion.

Vitals trial: defence moves to remove expert evidence over credentials and evasion
Defence lawyers in the Vitals hospital concession case have formally asked a Maltese court to strike out evidence submitted by both court-appointed experts, Times of Malta reports, citing concerns over professional qualifications and deliberate avoidance of testimony.
Lawyer Stefano Filletti, who represents former permanent secretaries Alfred Camilleri and Joseph Rapa as well as current permanent secretary Ronald Mizzi, led the application. All three are charged with fraud, fraudulent gains and misappropriation of public funds in connection with the Vitals concession. Fellow defence lawyer Franco Debono, also appearing for Camilleri, joined the challenge.
Questions over Milenovic's qualifications
Filletti and Debono targeted forensic accountant Miroslava Milenovic on the grounds that she lacked the professional warrant required to carry out forensic accountancy work in Malta. Filletti pointed to testimony from Accountancy Board representatives confirming that Milenovic held neither a Maltese accountancy warrant nor any qualifications that would entitle her to obtain one.
He further noted a Criminal Court decision ordering police action against Milenovic over allegations relating to her professional status and the work she carried out. Filletti argued she could not continue acting as a court expert while facing criminal proceedings connected to her profession. He requested that her full report and all evidence attributed to her be removed from the proceedings.
Milenovic had previously carried out work for the Maltese judiciary, including in the inquiry into offshore company Egrant — a case that exonerated former prime minister Joseph Muscat of wrongdoing.
Harbinson accused of deliberate evasion
On Jeremy Harbinson, Filletti told the court the forensic accountant had been deliberately avoiding testifying. Harbinson has refused on multiple occasions to appear in proceedings related to the Vitals hospital deal, citing fears for his personal safety. He has stated that his experience over recent years means he would "never return to Malta", and has also declined to testify remotely.
Earlier this year, a court heard that Harbinson was stopped at a Dutch border crossing, yet his precise whereabouts remain unknown to the court. Filletti described this pattern as deliberate evasion and argued that the accused could not be expected to wait indefinitely for his testimony. He also pointed to Harbinson's stated relinquishment of his professional warrant as a further ground for exclusion.
Filletti requested that all evidence associated with Harbinson likewise be struck from the record.
Prosecution team
The case for the prosecution is being led by Attorney General lawyers Francesco Rafalo and Rebekah Spiteri, alongside police inspectors Wayne Rodney Borg, Rennie Stivala and Anthony Rotin from the Financial Crimes Investigations Department.
Source: Times of Malta