Fresno jury convicts Stewart Coleman of first-degree murder in shooting death
A Fresno County jury found Stewart Coleman guilty of first-degree murder for killing Carl Johnson at a family property in August 2025. The case now moves to an insanity phase.

Fresno man convicted of murder after jury rejects accident and self-defence claims
A Fresno County jury has found Stewart Coleman guilty of first-degree murder for the shooting death of Carl Johnson, abc30.com reports. Jurors delivered the verdict after roughly four hours of deliberations, also finding Coleman guilty of a firearm discharge enhancement.
Johnson had visited the family property in August 2025 to collect fishing gear belonging to Coleman's late father, a longtime friend of Johnson's. During the encounter, Coleman shot Johnson in the chest outside a shed.
"It's like we were frozen in time, waiting for this one answer. We have it, and so we could at least know that we've stood up for Carl Johnson as much as we could up to this point," Johnson's son, John Johnson, said outside the court.
Senior Deputy District Attorney Amber Collins told jurors the evidence left no room for doubt. "He followed Mr. Johnson outside of a shed. Then shot him in his chest, killing him," Collins argued during closing statements. Prosecutors also pointed to what they described as shifting and inconsistent accounts Coleman gave to investigators, emergency dispatchers and the jury itself.
"He changes his story continuously, and each time he tells it, he makes it worse and worse and worse. The punches increase, the amount of time increases, and the story changes," Collins said.
Prosecutors highlighted Coleman's behaviour on the 911 call as particularly telling. "He's refusing to tell 911 who was shot when he knows exactly who that individual was," Collins argued. "That continues when he's asked, 'Where's the shooter? Where's the shooter right now?' ... 'I don't know' ... he's the shooter."
Defence attorney Blaine Sullivan maintained throughout the trial that the killing was not murder. "This case is not a murder. All right, it's an extremely tragic accident," Sullivan told jurors. Sullivan argued his client was frightened and believed Johnson posed a threat. "My client said, 'Carl told me he was a friend,' and my client believed him. That's why my client was so shocked when Carl came back towards him," Sullivan said.
Coleman testified that Johnson punched him during the confrontation. Prosecutors countered with photographs and investigator testimony showing no visible injuries on Coleman.
The jury of seven men and five women sided with the prosecution. Johnson's family were visibly emotional as the verdict was read. "Our whole future rested on it... and we got the verdict we wanted, and it's a step in the right direction," John Johnson said.
The case is not yet concluded. Because Coleman entered a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, jurors will now proceed to a second phase of the trial, in which they must determine whether Coleman was legally insane at the time of the shooting. That finding will determine whether he serves his sentence in state prison or is committed to a state hospital.
Source: Google News MT — Crime (en)