Mother sues driver and NYC over wrong-way crash that killed daughter, 27

Gudrun Schoeck filed a wrongful death lawsuit over the November 2025 death of her daughter Valerie, struck by a wrong-way driver in Greenwich Village. The suit names the driver, the city, and a rental company.

Mother sues driver and NYC over wrong-way crash that killed daughter, 27

Wrongful death suit targets driver, city, and rental firm after fatal Greenwich Village crash

Gudrun Schoeck filed a wrongful death lawsuit Wednesday in Manhattan Supreme Court against the driver who struck and killed her 27-year-old daughter in Greenwich Village last November, NY Post Metro reports. The suit also names New York City and a car rental company as defendants.

Valerie Bettina Schoeck, a Massachusetts native who had been living in the West Village, was crossing Morton Street at Seventh Avenue South on Nov. 6, 2025, when Gary Levinson drove the wrong way down Morton Street and hit her with a 2020 GMC van, according to officials.

A "One-Way" sign was absent from the one-way street at the time of the crash, the lawsuit states. The city was "careless and negligent" for failing to install or maintain "adequate, visible, clear, and properly positioned traffic signs" while repaving and redesigning the street, the filing adds. That failure, the suit claims, left Valerie Schoeck at "unreasonable risk of harm" despite the city having prior notice of the dangerous conditions.

Levinson was arrested last February and charged with criminally negligent homicide and reckless driving. In May, he pleaded guilty to one count of criminally negligent homicide and was sentenced to a five-year suspension of his professional license and a three-year conditional discharge, avoiding prison entirely.

The suit also names Courier Car Rental, Levinson's employer and the owner of the van he was driving at the time of the crash.

"The simplest of acts by each Defendant could have prevented this unspeakable tragedy," said Imran Ansari, attorney for the mother. "Their failure to do so requires accountability and each Defendant must answer to the law."

Levinson could not be reached for comment.

Valerie Schoeck grew up in Boston's South End with her mother and sister. She attended the College of Charleston, then moved to New York, where she worked as a vice president at PR firm Argot Partners. Her wedding had been planned for the following June.

"We will keep seeking the truth, accountability, and justice she deserves," Gudrun Schoeck said in a statement. "We believe every party responsible must answer for the loss of our Valerie."

"Valerie's death has left our family wrapped in silence and emptiness that no words can ever fill," her mother added. "But we will carry her memory with tenderness and strength, refusing to let the light she brought into our lives grow dim."

Source: NY Post Metro