Madison Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson Cleared After Fatal Shooting of Corey Ruiz

Dane County DA Ismael Ozanne declined to charge any officers in the July 22 shooting death of Corey Ruiz. The Ruiz family's attorney called the killing "textbook excessive force."

Madison Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson Cleared After Fatal Shooting of Corey Ruiz

No Charges for Officer Who Shot Corey Ruiz in Madison, Wisconsin

Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday that he will not file charges against any of the officers involved in the fatal police shooting of Corey Ruiz, a 38-year-old Black man killed on July 22 in Madison, Wisconsin, wpr.org reports.

"I conclude it was reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers while officers attempted to take him into custody," Ozanne stated in a news release.

The officer who fired the fatal shots, Kiel Baitinger-Peterson, had been on paid administrative leave along with three other officers since the shooting. Baitinger-Peterson has just over a decade of law enforcement experience.

Family and Attorneys Dispute the Decision

Members of the Ruiz family met with Ozanne and the county medical examiner earlier Thursday before the announcement was made public. At a subsequent news conference, Corey's mother, Elsa Ruiz, spoke through sobs.

"I have to live with every day of him not being here," she said. "It hurts so bad not to have him here … He was loved. He was cared for."

Ben Crump, an attorney for the Ruiz family, said the district attorney should have filed charges. "We don't believe any of the shots were justified," Crump told reporters. "Not the first shot, not the second shot and definitely not the third shot. The kill shot to his head was not justified. It was the textbook definition of excessive use of force."

What the Investigation Found

The Division of Criminal Investigation within Wisconsin's Department of Justice investigated the shooting and forwarded its findings to Ozanne's office. A 2014 state law requires that an outside agency investigate any officer-involved death.

According to the DCI and Madison police, the encounter began when Ruiz fled on a bicycle after officers responded to reports of a man checking car doors and an alleged attempted burglary. During a struggle with police, Ruiz produced a knife, which led to Baitinger-Peterson being injured.

Bystander cellphone video of the confrontation circulated widely online. That footage shows Ruiz approaching an intersection on a bike before falling to the pavement, with multiple officers attempting to detain him. While Ruiz was on the ground, Baitinger-Peterson fired three shots.

"Mr. Ruiz was hit with two of the three shots; once in the torso and once in the head," Ozanne's release stated. Two other officers had attempted to deploy a Taser during the encounter, but the device malfunctioned. "One set of Taser prongs made contact with Mr. Ruiz's left hand," Ozanne wrote. "The other set of Taser prongs were on Mr. Ruiz's left side. Mr. Ruiz fell or was taken to the ground just before three shots were fired."

Attorneys for the Ruiz family questioned why gunshots were necessary while Ruiz was already down on the pavement.

Protests and Encampment Followed the Shooting

The shooting at the intersection of South Baldwin and Williamson streets — known locally as Willy Street — triggered a sustained wave of protests across Madison, including demonstrations at the state Capitol. Mourners erected a makeshift memorial at the site, which expanded into a multi-block encampment with tents, mattresses, and grills that blocked traffic for nearly two weeks.

On August 4, Madison Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway ordered the encampment cleared, citing harm to nearby residents and businesses. People who were homeless and living at the site were given hotel vouchers before officials moved in.

Oversight Disputes and Pending Proceedings

Madison's former interim Police Monitor, Aeiramique Glass, had pledged to conduct an independent investigation into the shooting and demanded records including dashboard camera footage. The city attorney's office said state law prevented releasing those records without approval from the DCI and the Dane County District Attorney.

In October, Madison's Common Council voted 14–6 to fire Glass, citing performance issues. The city's Police Civilian Oversight Board has since appointed former City Alder Rebecca Kemble as interim monitor, a move that has triggered a legal dispute with the city attorney's office.

Separately, Green Bay Police recommended that Glass be charged with obstructing and resisting an officer, as well as battery to an officer, following a physical altercation with Madison police near the site of a protest close to where Ruiz was shot. Glass has denied wrongdoing. Ozanne has not announced whether his office will pursue those charges.

Call to Fire the Officer

A local political action committee, Blacks for Political and Social Action of Dane County, has filed a complaint with Madison's Police and Fire Commission calling for Baitinger-Peterson's dismissal. The complaint accuses him of violating city policies, ordinances, and Wisconsin laws related to use of force, de-escalation, and professional conduct. It also calls for the other officers involved in Ruiz's arrest to be fired or suspended.

Source: NYT US News