Son-in-law shoots father-in-law in Chimbas following row over abuse: 12 years' sentence

Felipe Murúa fired three times at Alberto Alaniz in October 1978 in Chimbas and was sentenced to 12 years for manslaughter. The case is recounted in the podcast "Crime Stories" on tiempodesanjuan.com.

Son-in-law shoots father-in-law in Chimbas following row over abuse: 12 years' sentence

Three shots in Chimbas: the son-in-law who killed his father-in-law after years of family violence

According to tiempodesanjuan.com in chapter LXVI of its podcast "Crime Stories", available on Spotify, Alberto Alaniz and Felipe Murúa had shared barbecues, card games and a shared passion for boxing and motorcycles for years. That cohabitation ended on Saturday 14 October 1978, when Murúa fired three times at his father-in-law at the intersection of Urquiza Street and 25 de Mayo, in Chimbas.

Alaniz was a director of Sportivo Villa El Salvador Club and a member of the San Juan motorcycling association. Murúa boxed at Mocoroa Club and worked as a street vendor. The relationship deteriorated when problems began in the marriage between Murúa and Soledad Alaniz, Alberto's daughter and mother of two young children. Relatives of the young woman stated that Murúa abused her and beat her, and had introduced her to unsavoury circles. Separations and reconciliations became repetitive, and the father could no longer tolerate the situation.

The night of Friday the 13th

The first direct confrontation occurred on the night of Friday 13 October. Murúa was visiting a neighbour in the Villa El Salvador district when Alaniz had him called over. The discussion escalated rapidly: Alaniz warned his son-in-law to stop hitting his daughter, with the words "one day I'm going to kill you". Murúa responded by threatening his father-in-law that he would leave him "with his belly open".

The following day, around 16:00, the two men crossed paths again on Urquiza Street. Alaniz was cycling; Murúa was driving his Chevrolet. After stopping and resuming the discussion, the young man took a Tala revolver, .22 long calibre, that he was carrying on the passenger seat and fired three times. One bullet struck close to Alaniz's ear; the other two hit him in the abdomen.

Murúa fled in his truck. Alaniz, wounded, managed to walk to his sister's house, where his cousin Juan Bautista Ibaceta found him and assisted him. A neighbour took him to Guillermo Rawson Hospital, but he died in front of emergency room staff.

Three days on the run

The assailant first took refuge in his mother's house, where he left the weapon, and then in his cousin's home. He remained at large for three days, until he turned himself in at the Court on Tuesday 17 October.

The murder definitively fractured the family. Soledad did not attend her father's wake and decided to stay with Murúa, a choice that distanced her from her siblings for years.

The trial and sentence

The court proceedings took place in August 1979. During the trial, Murúa maintained that Alaniz had attacked him first with a knife, but no witness corroborated that version. It was established instead that the accused was carrying the .22 calibre revolver found in his mother's house. The prosecution requested that premeditation and treachery be considered as aggravating factors, although the judges did not find them proven. Murúa was sentenced to 12 years in prison for manslaughter.

He served part of his sentence at Chimbas Prison and regained his freedom six years after the crime. During his imprisonment, Soledad visited him regularly and, upon his release, they continued living together. Over time, Soledad's siblings resumed contact with her, but further arguments and estrangement eventually separated them. They heard nothing further from Soledad. They learned that Murúa had died three years before this account was published.

The episode is part of "Crime Stories", a production by tiempodesanjuan.com directed by Walter Vilca, Agostina Montaño and Adrián Caravajal, with a new chapter available each week on Spotify.

Source: Google News PR — San Juan

Read this article in the original language