Serial killer Simon Levy found guilty of two murders after string of Met Police failures
A jury at the Old Bailey convicted Simon Levy of murdering two women and raping a third in London, after police, prosecutors and courts made a series of failures that left him free.
Serial killer Simon Levy convicted after repeated system failures left him free to attack
A jury at the Old Bailey has found Simon Levy, 40, guilty of murdering Carmenza Valencia-Trujillo, 53, and Sheryl Wilkins, 39, in London last year, as well as the violent rape of a third woman in a car park. The BBC has reported that police, prosecutors and courts made a series of disastrous decisions that allowed Levy to remain free throughout.
Levy, a jobless loner who lived with his mother, carried out the attacks while on bail for sexual assaults on women on public transport in London. He went on to commit further assaults on trains even as the criminal justice system repeatedly released him.
A catalogue of institutional failures
The Sun and the BBC have detailed the failures that allowed Levy to continue offending over several years. Among the most significant:
The Metropolitan Police downgraded Levy's risk classification to women upon his release from prison in 2024, a decision now under investigation by the police watchdog. He had already served a prison sentence for the sexual assault of two women at public events in London in 2018.
The Met closed its investigation into a rape Levy carried out in January 2025, despite the fact he could have been identified from available evidence. When Valencia-Trujillo was killed in March 2025, the force did not classify her death as a murder or pass the case to specialist homicide detectives until after Levy had killed again.
British Transport Police's (BTP) investigation into Levy's assaults on trains was beset by delays. He was not charged for more than six months despite having been filmed committing an attack. Both the Met and BTP returned a stolen travelcard to Levy, which allowed him to travel without paying — and to commit further crimes, including the first murder.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) is also criticised for acting too slowly in its handling of a sexual assault Levy committed against a prison officer while he was already in custody. The Met took three years to investigate and charge him for that offence.
"Collective system failure"
Deputy Assistant Commissioner Kevin Southworth, from the Met, told the BBC the case represented a "collective system failure" and was "a tragedy beyond words". He acknowledged that the life of Sheryl Wilkins could have been saved, and said the force had apologised to her family.
Det Ch Supt Pete Fulton, from BTP, said the delay in his force's investigation "absolutely wasn't good enough" and attributed it to "incompetence" by two officers who have since been moved to other roles. The CPS has apologised for "shortcomings" in its efforts to have Levy remanded in custody.
One of the ten women Levy assaulted on public transport told the BBC: "It didn't need to take all of those women for Simon Levy to be finally put into prison — the attacks could have been prevented." She said learning of his other victims and the repeated bail decisions "was worse than even the physical assault".
A history of warnings ignored
Levy first came to the attention of the Met in 2017 when a woman reported him for sexually assaulting her at an event in south London. The CPS ruled out charging him — a decision now viewed as a mistake.
In 2021, he received a three-year prison sentence for assaulting two women at separate public events in London in summer 2018. Despite describing the offences as "extremely serious", Judge Christopher Hehir declined to impose a Sexual Harm Prevention Order upon Levy's release, saying the draft order was too broad. Police and prosecutors did not challenge that decision.
When Levy was first released from prison on licence in 2023, he was initially classified as a high-risk sex offender and managed by multiple agencies, including the Met and the Probation Service. That classification was subsequently downgraded.
At the home he shared with his mother, police found a computer containing notes about sexual activity and records, as well as plastic bags stuffed with newspaper articles about rape and murder. He had also shown an interest in the misogynistic influencer Andrew Tate.
Questions over Met's record on reform
The Met's failures in Levy's case come after the force repeatedly stated it had reformed in the wake of earlier scandals — including the murder of Sarah Everard by a serving Metropolitan Police officer, and the force's failure to detect and stop serial killer Stephen Port.
Met Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley has repeatedly rejected the formal finding by Baroness Louise Casey that the force is institutionally sexist and misogynistic. Levy's case is expected to bring renewed scrutiny to that position.
The details of Levy's crimes on public transport, together with the assault on a prison officer, were subject to reporting restrictions until now. He was convicted of those offences in February. The murders and rape were confirmed by the Old Bailey jury in the most recent proceedings.
Source: The Sun