138 Cannabis Plants, One-Day Sentence: Federal Case in St. Croix Raises Questions

Mikey Luke was convicted of maintaining a marijuana grow site in St. Croix and sentenced to just one day in federal custody. The case highlights legal uncertainty for growers under Virgin Islands cannabis law.

138 Cannabis Plants, One-Day Sentence: Federal Case in St. Croix Raises Questions

St. Croix Man Sentenced to One Day in Federal Cannabis Case Involving 138 Plants

A federal judge in St. Croix sentenced Mikey Luke to a single day in federal custody on Monday — time he served the same day — after a jury convicted him of maintaining a property for the purpose of manufacturing marijuana, newsfeed.wtjx.org reports. The sentence, handed down by U.S. District Judge Timothy Savage, also includes three years of supervised release, the first six months of which will be served on home incarceration with location monitoring. Luke may leave his home only for medical needs or employment.

Luke was arrested on September 28, 2021, after a 911 call reported he was growing marijuana at his home in Estate Anna's Hope. Virgin Islands Police Department officers responded, and Luke signed a consent-to-search form after acknowledging that marijuana plants were growing on the property. Officers initially collected approximately 178 plants; DEA agents later counted 138. Luke was not a licensed cannabis cultivator at the time of his arrest.

A federal complaint was sworn that same day by VIPD Sergeant Aldemar Santos, who has served as a deputized task force officer with the DEA's High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area task force since 2009. Luke made his initial appearance before U.S. Magistrate Judge George Cannon Jr. that day.

During a recorded interview with federal agents, Luke initially said the marijuana was for personal use but later acknowledged selling it to others. A jury ultimately acquitted him of the distribution charge but convicted him of maintaining the grow property. Federal prosecutors had charged Luke by information on October 26, 2021, with a superseding indictment returned in October 2023.

Prosecution Sought 27 Months; Judge Departed Sharply

The presentence report set an advisory sentencing range of 21 to 27 months. Prosecutors pushed for the maximum, with Assistant U.S. Attorney Truman Coe citing Luke's criminal history — including 10 prior felony offenses, among them a 2010 drug conviction — and writing that Luke "has declined to express any remorse for his criminal lifestyle."

Defense attorney Kye Walker asked for probation. In her sentencing memorandum, Walker described Luke's Rastafari faith and his use of marijuana as a sacrament. She also noted that Luke had used marijuana tea to manage pain from bladder stones that went undiagnosed for years; doctors eventually found more than 1,000 calcified fragments requiring surgery.

Walker told reporters that Judge Savage did not accept the defense's lower plant count argument — the defense contended only 12 of 26 samples tested positive and that some plants were hemp — but did weigh Luke's acquittal on the distribution charge, his cooperation, his medical condition, and his Rastafari upbringing.

"He exercised his discretion to not sentence pursuant to the guidelines but instead sentence pursuant to the particular circumstances that were unique to Mr. Luke, unique to his background, unique to his character," Walker said.

Luke was also ordered to pay a $100 special assessment.

Federal Law Applies Regardless of Territorial Framework

The case has drawn attention because the Virgin Islands has its own cannabis laws: a medical cannabis law enacted in 2019, followed by the Cannabis Use Act of 2023, which established an adult-use and sacramental framework. Those territorial statutes do not, however, eliminate federal jurisdiction over marijuana offenses.

Steven Phillip Sr., law enforcement coordinator and public affairs officer for the U.S. Attorney's Office, said the office is bound by federal law, not local law. "The U.S. Attorney's Office follows U.S. DOJ laws and policies," he said. "We don't follow local law." Phillip said Luke was prosecuted federally because of the number of plants found at his home.

Asked whether the office prosecutes growers who comply with Virgin Islands cannabis laws, Phillip said he would need to check with U.S. Attorney Adam Sleeper. The office had not responded by publication time.

Walker said growers who operate under local law remain at risk of federal prosecution. "There is always a possibility that they could be charged because it would still be considered a violation of federal law," she said. She noted, however, that the U.S. Department of Justice "has issued memos over time where they're deprioritizing those types of cases."

In April 2026, the DOJ moved FDA-approved marijuana products and marijuana covered by qualifying state-issued medical marijuana licenses from Schedule I to Schedule III under the Controlled Substances Act. The reclassification did not broadly legalize recreational marijuana federally. Marijuana outside those specific categories remained in Schedule I.

Walker said she is not aware of any federal cases targeting growers who are in compliance with state or territorial cannabis laws, and she believes federal authorities are more focused on tax matters and interstate transportation than on locally compliant cultivation.

Attorney Who Helped Draft the Territorial Law Advises Compliance

Walker helped draft the Virgin Islands Cannabis Use Act and described the inclusion of protections for Rastafari sacramental use as "a personal and professional achievement." She advised Virgin Islanders who grow marijuana to comply with the Cannabis Use Act "to the greatest extent possible" and to obtain the required licenses and registrations.

She also called for removing marijuana from the federal drug schedules entirely.

"Let's focus on drugs like cocaine and meth and fentanyl," Walker said. "I mean, why are we still spending money prosecuting marijuana crimes?"

Source: Google News VI — Crime