Fugitive Guilty in Charlotte Amalie Shooting Death of Cecil Scatliffe
Demare Encarnacion pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter after fleeing to the BVI. Sentencing is set for Jan. 7, 2027.
Guilty plea ends trial in Charlotte Amalie fatal shooting
A last-minute plea agreement on Monday halted jury selection in the murder trial of Demare A. Encarnacion, nearly two years after a street argument on St. Thomas ended in a fatal shooting. According to stthomassource.com, Superior Court Judge Renee Andre accepted the guilty plea and scheduled a sentencing hearing for Jan. 7, 2027.
Encarnacion admitted to one count of involuntary manslaughter in the death of 59-year-old Cecil Scatliffe and one count of unauthorized weapons possession. Emergency services were alerted via the 911 call center on Oct. 18, 2024, and officers found Scatliffe lying unresponsive on Kronprindsens Gade shortly after 3 a.m.
Three witnesses told investigators they observed Encarnacion and Scatliffe arguing in public moments before four gunshots were fired. One witness reported seeing Encarnacion approach Scatliffe with a firearm. A third witness stated their vehicle was struck by a stray bullet. All three witnesses told police they could identify the shooter by sight, and two of them selected Encarnacion's image from a mug shot photo array. Surveillance footage from the area corroborated the witness accounts of a verbal altercation followed by gunfire.
After the shooting, Encarnacion evaded arrest for approximately three months. The Royal Virgin Islands Police Force notified the Virgin Islands Police Department and the U.S. Marshals Service Fugitive Task Force on March 18, 2025, that Encarnacion was in their custody. He was subsequently extradited to St. Thomas and held on $1 million bail pending trial.
Source: Google News VI — Crime