Murder suspect pleads guilty to manslaughter in Charlotte Amalie shooting
Demare Encarnacion pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter in the 2024 fatal shooting of Cecil Scatliffe on St. Thomas. Sentencing is set for January 2027.
Fugitive extradited from BVI enters guilty plea in St. Thomas homicide case
A man accused of fatally shooting a 59-year-old on a Charlotte Amalie street in October 2024 has pleaded guilty to a lesser charge, stcroixsource.com reports. Demare A. Encarnacion admitted guilt to one count of involuntary manslaughter and one count of unauthorized weapons possession in Superior Court.
Jury selection in Encarnacion's murder trial had been scheduled to begin Monday before Superior Court Judge Renee Andre, but a last-minute plea agreement brought proceedings to a halt. Judge Andre accepted the guilty plea and scheduled a sentencing hearing for Jan. 7, 2027.
A 911 alert on Oct. 18, 2024, shortly after 3 a.m., led officers to Kronprindsens Gade, where they found Cecil Scatliffe lying unresponsive. Scatliffe was 59 years old.
Three witnesses told investigators they had observed the confrontation. One said they saw Encarnacion and Scatliffe arguing in public moments before hearing four gunshots. A second witness said they saw Encarnacion approach Scatliffe with a firearm in hand. A third reported that a stray bullet struck their vehicle at the scene.
All three witnesses told police they could identify the shooter by sight. Two of them picked Encarnacion's image from a mug shot photo array. Surveillance footage gathered from the area corroborated the witness accounts of a verbal altercation followed by gunfire, according to court documents.
After the shooting, Encarnacion apparently fled to the British Virgin Islands. Authorities spent roughly three months searching for him before the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force notified the Virgin Islands Police Department and the U.S. Marshals Service Fugitive Task Force that they had him in custody. He was extradited to St. Thomas on March 18, 2025, and held on $1 million bail pending trial.
Source: Google News VI — Crime