Paris: twelve months' imprisonment for violence at Gare du Nord

A man on day release has been sentenced to twelve months' imprisonment for assaulting a homeless person at Gare du Nord with his safety boots. The court rejected the allegation of weapon use.

Paris: twelve months' imprisonment for violence at Gare du Nord

Paris court: conviction for aggravated assault while on day release

According to jss.fr, the 23rd chamber of Paris court sentenced Xavier M., a man in his fifties, to twelve months' imprisonment with a remand order for violence with aggravating circumstances. The man was on day release at La Santé when he committed these acts at Gare du Nord.

Xavier M. was accused of striking an unconscious man on the platform of line 5, inflicting open wounds on him, notably to his left tibia. Surveillance footage recorded several kicks and punches. Police found traces of blood on the sole of his reinforced safety boots.

The prosecution had cited three aggravating circumstances: weapon use, acts committed after drug consumption (cannabis, cocaine, amphetamines) and commission of the crime in a location providing access to a means of transport. Video analysis revealed no trace of a blade weapon.

Xavier M. presented his version of events in court. He described his victim as a troublesome "crack dealer" who harassed elderly women to beg for loose change. According to him, he intervened to defend them. He also claimed that the victim was already wounded before the altercation: "He had a large scar, which meant that the blows I struck with my boot aggravated the injuries."

The assessor noted that "a considerable amount of blood" had been observed by police. Xavier M. justified this by the heat, the victim's blood-alcohol level and the resulting haemorrhage. He insisted: "It wasn't me who gave him all those scars."

His criminal record contains 26 entries accumulated over as many years, essentially for crimes against property and drug offences. He expressed his regrets in his final statement: "I really regret this incident. If the court grants me this final chance, I will try to do better."

The prosecution noted "rather positive behaviour" and an acknowledgement of facts, but could "not fail to apply for a remand order" in view of his record and the fact that Xavier M. "had no room for error" on day release. It sought twelve months' imprisonment, stating that "there is only one person injured in this case, and that is the victim."

The defence contested that the serious injury had been caused by the boot and highlighted inconsistencies in the victim's account. It also argued that boots were not a weapon within the meaning of criminal law and that no incident had occurred during his day release. It called for a suspended sentence or even a return to day release.

The court rejected the aggravating circumstance of weapon use but upheld the sentence of twelve months' imprisonment with a remand order.

Source: Google News FR — Crime (fr)

Read this article in the original language