Fenech Requests Chief Justice Chetcuti's Recusal in Caruana Galizia Murder Appeal

Yorgen Fenech's lawyers argue Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti has already ruled on issues central to his defence. The prosecution called the move an abuse of the judicial process.

Fenech Requests Chief Justice Chetcuti's Recusal in Caruana Galizia Murder Appeal

Fenech Challenges Chief Justice's Impartiality in Caruana Galizia Appeal

Yorgen Fenech has formally requested that Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti step aside from hearing the appeal in the murder case of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia, Times of Malta reports. The application was heard before the chief justice himself, sitting alongside judges Doreen Clarke and Josette Demicoli.

Fenech was acquitted on 2 September following a 55-day jury trial. The jury returned an 8–1 verdict in his favour on two charges — complicity in wilful homicide and criminal association — relating to the car bomb assassination of investigative journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia on 16 October 2017.

Grounds for Recusal

Fenech's lawyers argued that Chief Justice Chetcuti had already expressed a position on matters central to the defence's case in a prior Constitutional Court judgment. That ruling, delivered by a bench comprising Chetcuti alongside judges Giannino Caruana Demajo and Anthony Ellul, concluded that Assistant Commissioner Keith Arnaud was a credible witness and that there had been no lack of impartiality in the police investigation.

The defence also pointed to the Constitutional Court's finding that it was justified for police not to have initially considered Keith Schembri as a suspect. Fenech's legal team maintains that Schembri received preferential treatment and that key evidence was lost from his office at Castille.

Lawyer Giannella De Marco told the court that during a search of Schembri's home, Arnaud had instructed scene-of-crime officers to seize only the electronic devices that Schembri himself identified. She also noted that Arnaud had a private WhatsApp exchange with Schembri on his personal mobile phone, and that no request was made to clone the device.

"In his testimony, Arnaud referred to Schembri as an old family friend," De Marco said.

The defence invoked the European Convention on Human Rights judgment in Micallef vs Malta, which holds that a judge must abstain when circumstances could give rise to a reasonable impression of a lack of objective or subjective impartiality.

Prosecution Objects

The prosecution, acting on behalf of the Attorney General, rejected the application. Lawyer Godwin Cini argued that the basis of Fenech's claim was flawed, contending that the Constitutional Court judgment dealt exclusively with Keith Arnaud's involvement and that the defence had selectively omitted portions of that ruling.

Cini noted that the Constitutional Court judgment had also acknowledged the shortcomings of the investigation — a point the defence failed to include in its application.

On the Micallef vs Malta precedent cited by Fenech's lawyers, the prosecution argued that "the fear of partiality must be objectively justified." It drew a distinction with that case, in which the judge was the uncle and brother of the opposing party's lawyer — direct family ties considered sufficient to raise a legitimate doubt. No equivalent personal connection exists here, the prosecution maintained.

Cini further argued that the legal framework governing judicial recusal had changed since the Micallef vs Malta ruling. "The fact that a member of the judiciary has made decisions or acquired knowledge of the evidence does not, in itself, mean that they are prejudiced," he said.

The prosecution also warned that while recusal is a right, it "should not be used as a tool to choose the court or to prolong proceedings," describing such use as "an abuse of the judicial process under the guise of a fear of alleged partiality."

Parties Present

Caruana Galizia's husband and sisters attended the hearing. The prosecution team comprised lawyers Godwin Cini, Anthony Vella and Danica Vella on behalf of the Attorney General. Fenech was represented by Giannella De Marco, Charles Mercieca and Gianluca Caruana Carrun. Lawyers Therese Comodini Cachia and Jason Azzopardi appeared for the Caruana Galizia family.

Source: Times of Malta