Fenech seeks Chief Justice Chetcuti's recusal from Daphne murder appeal

Yorgen Fenech's defence has asked Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti to step aside from the AG's appeal against Fenech's acquittal. A ruling on the recusal is due 10th December.

Fenech seeks Chief Justice Chetcuti's recusal from Daphne murder appeal

Fenech defence challenges Chief Justice's impartiality in Daphne Caruana Galizia appeal

Yorgen Fenech has formally requested that Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti recuse himself from the Attorney General's appeal against Fenech's acquittal in the murder of Daphne Caruana Galizia. Lovin Malta reports, citing MaltaToday, that the defence raised the impartiality concern during court proceedings on Wednesday.

Fenech's lawyers argued that Chetcuti had previously sat on a Constitutional Court bench that described Assistant Commissioner Keith Arnaud's testimony as credible and consistent. Arnaud's credibility — and alleged shortcomings in the police investigation — had formed a central plank of the defence strategy throughout the murder trial.

The prosecution opposed the application, contending that the earlier judgment dealt with distinct legal issues and that no legitimate grounds existed for a recusal. It also cautioned against recusal requests being deployed as a mechanism for selecting which judges preside over specific cases.

Fenech was acquitted of all charges on 2nd September following an eight-to-one jury verdict. The Attorney General subsequently filed an appeal citing alleged procedural irregularities during the trial.

The court, sitting as an appeals bench comprising Chief Justice Chetcuti, Madam Justice Doreen Clarke and Madam Justice Josette Demicoli, is scheduled to rule on the recusal request on 10th December.

The prosecution was led by AG lawyers Godwin Cini, Anthony Vella and Danika Vella. The defence was represented by Gianella De Marco, Charles Mercieca and Gianluca Caruana Curran. Lawyers Therese Comodini Cachia and Jason Azzopardi appeared on behalf of the parte civile.

Source: Lovin Malta