Apple to face trial in 2027 for alleged iPhone planned obsolescence

Apple will appear before the Paris magistrate's court starting 17 June 2027, accused of deliberately reducing the lifespan of certain iPhones to force consumers to replace them more frequently.

Apple to face trial in 2027 for alleged iPhone planned obsolescence

Apple before the courts over planned obsolescence

The Paris public prosecutor has summoned Apple to appear for four days before the Paris magistrate's court starting 17 June 2027, according to TF1 Info. The precise dates will be set at a preliminary hearing on 25 February 2027. The American giant is being prosecuted for intentionally reducing the lifespan of certain iPhone models in order to push consumers to replace them more regularly.

The company is suspected of having blocked repairs on a series of models between November 2021 and July 2024, notably the iPhone XS, the iPhone 15 Pro Max, the iPhone SE 2020 and 2022, as well as the iPhone 12, 13 and 14. According to investigators, Apple allegedly used a system for verifying the serial number of components to disable certain features when devices are repaired outside its official network. Facial recognition Face ID in particular could be disabled when the front camera was replaced. The battery health status indicator was also reportedly affected.

This procedure followed a complaint filed by the organisation Halte à l'obsolescence programmée (Hop) on 7 December 2022. Laetitia Vasseur, general delegate and co-founder of Hop, believes that a conviction would constitute "a historic first in France and in the world". The organisation emphasises that the investigation lasted four years and reflects the determination of the authorities in the face of practices unduly limiting the repair of electronic products.

Since 2021, article L441-3 of the Consumer Code has made obstruction of repair a specific offence associated with planned obsolescence, in order to protect the environment and consumers. Apple faces a fine of up to 300,000 euros, or even a percentage of its annual turnover. The company firmly contests the accusations, stating that it "designs durable products accompanied by software updates enabling users to keep their devices longer". The investigations were conducted by the General Directorate for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Prevention (DGCCRF).

Source: TF1 Info

Read this article in the original language